If you are weighing up what to do with an unused chimney stack in West Row, this page explains the materials involved in a proper take-down and what the honest pros and cons of each approach are.
Call any time. Calls are answered day and night and passed straight to our roofers.
Many homeowners with a redundant chimney stack try to ignore the problem. The stack is not used, the fireplace has been blocked off, and it sits there looking harmless. The reality is that an unmaintained stack above your roofline is exposed to rain, frost and wind 365 days a year with no benefit to your home at all. Taking it down to below roofline level is the only permanent way to stop that exposure.
A properly executed take-down is not simply demolition. The roof has to be remade where the stack once sat, and the materials chosen for that reinstatement affect how long the result lasts and how it looks. It pays to understand your options before the scaffold goes up.
Regardless of which materials are used for the finished roof, every chimney take-down requires scaffold. Working from a ladder on a sloping roof near a chimney stack is not safe, and it does not allow bricks to be lowered properly without risk of damaging the tiles below. Any quote that does not include scaffold should be questioned.
For a standard residential stack on a two-storey property in West Row, a typical scaffold takes half a day to erect and another half day to strike. That time is built into a properly priced job.
Once the stack is down and the opening in the roof is exposed, the covering has to be reinstated. The right material depends on what your existing roof is made from and what your priorities are.
The most common approach for tiled roofs is to infill the gap with matching or closely matching tiles. On a relatively modern roof with standard concrete interlocking tiles, a good match is usually straightforward. On older clay plain-tiled roofs the match can be harder to find - reclaimed tiles are sometimes the only way to get close in colour and texture.
Pros: Looks as though the chimney was never there. Durable. No ongoing maintenance once bedded and pointed correctly.
Cons: Colour match is not always perfect, especially on weathered clay tiles. Reclaimed tiles add to material cost and sourcing time. The underlying felt, battens and rafters must be in good condition for the new tiles to sit correctly.
On slate roofs, the infill patch should use the same type of slate where possible. Natural Welsh or Spanish slate is the preferred match for existing natural slate. Fibre-cement slates are an economical alternative but have a different surface texture and do not weather the same way, so the patch may remain visible.
Pros: Natural slate is long-lasting and weathers well. Fibre-cement is cheaper and readily available.
Cons: Natural slate costs more per unit. A close match in thickness and colour requires care when sourcing. A patch on a large, older slate roof will almost always be visible on close inspection, whatever material is used.
At the point where the stack met the roof, there will be an existing lead apron, back gutter and side flashings. Once the stack is removed, this lead is cut back, the roof timbers are assessed, and new lead is dressed in to seal the junction between the new tiles and the surrounding roof. This is skilled work - poorly fitted lead is one of the most common causes of leaks after a chimney take-down.
Lead is specified by its code (thickness). Code 4 is the minimum for flashings and aprons on a residential roof; Code 5 is used where a back gutter needs to handle significant water run-off. On a large roof with a valley behind the old stack position, getting the lead specification right matters more than the tile choice.
After take-down, a short stub of brickwork typically remains just below the tile level. This stub is sealed at the top with a mortar fillet or a lead cap, and it is surrounded by correctly dressed lead flashing where it meets the tiles. The stub needs no further maintenance once it is sealed properly.
Some homeowners ask whether the stub can be taken right down to rafter level to eliminate any masonry entirely. This is possible but more involved - it means cutting into the ceiling below and making good the plaster, and it adds both time and cost. For most homes the stub-below-roofline finish is perfectly adequate and far less disruptive.
The flue opening must be closed off at the point where the stack is taken down. A ventilated cap or a solid mortar closure is fitted depending on whether the flue connects to any remaining fireplace void that needs airflow. If the flue is being entirely decommissioned and the fireplace opening below has already been sealed, a solid mortar closure is fine. If there is still a fireplace void that could trap moisture or allow condensation to form, some ventilation is needed - this is worth discussing with your roofer before the job starts.
A chimney take-down generates a significant weight of old bricks, mortar and broken pot. On a typical two-pot stack you might see 300 to 500 bricks removed plus the old lead. All of this needs to come off the scaffold and be taken away.
A roofer who cannot answer those questions clearly before starting work is one to be cautious of.
We carry out chimney take-downs for homeowners in West Row and the surrounding villages, working from our base in Mildenhall. If you would like us to look at your stack and talk you through the options, call us to arrange a roof survey.
No obligation · We'll call you to arrange a free visit
Call any time. Calls are answered day and night and passed straight to our roofers.